Pool Heater Buying Guide for 2023

Embarking on the journey of finding the perfect pool heater can be quite overwhelming.

Indeed, when it’s time to upgrade or install a new one, the biggest challenge is…

Navigating through our comprehensive pool heater buying guide.

Many homeowners are clueless about where to start. But this is what distinguishes an informed buyer from an impulsive shopper. If you don’t understand how to choose the right pool heater wisely, you might end up with something that doesn’t meet your needs.

Selecting the ideal pool heater isn’t easy, folks.

To illustrate this point, consider a homeowner who recently shared his experience of purchasing a high-end gas pool heater only to realize later that his location didn’t have natural gas access!

This unfortunate event left him apprehensive about making.

Understanding Different Types of Pool Heaters

The selection of a pool heater can have significant implications on your swimming experience and energy consumption. The main contenders in the arena are gas pool heaters and heat pumps, each presenting its own unique set of benefits and limitations.

Gas Pool Heaters: How They Work and Their Benefits

A gas pool heater operates by igniting natural gas or propane within a combustion chamber. This process heats up the water that circulates from the pool through the system before it’s returned back to the pool at an elevated temperature. One notable advantage this type offers is its capacity for swift temperature increases, irrespective of external weather conditions.

This quick heating capability makes them ideal candidates for pools used infrequently or over short durations, such as during social gatherings where immediate heating may be required. Furthermore, they generally present a lower upfront cost compared to other types.

Limitations of Using Gas Pool Heaters

In spite of all their perks, there are certain drawbacks associated with using gas heaters worth considering prior to making any decisions. For instance, these tend to consume more energy, which could translate into higher utility bills when frequently utilized.

Besides, the complexity of safety requirements for handling combustible gases might necessitate professional installation, potentially adding extra costs to the initial purchase price. Lastly, local regulations concerning emissions resulting from the burning of fossil fuels like natural gas or propane could limit usage in some areas, depending on the specific rules in place.

Heat Pumps as Pool Heaters: Advantages and Drawbacks

Heat pump pool heaters, unlike traditional models, generate heat directly via fuel combustion; they work by capturing ambient air and transferring it into your swimming pool’s water. This method ensures efficient utilization of electricity, making them cost-effective despite being pricier initially compared to their traditional counterparts. Moreover, since systems don’t rely on fossil fuels but rather renewable sources (ambient air), they contribute towards environmental conservation efforts while still ensuring comfortable temperatures throughout most seasons except extremely cold winters, when efficiency drops drastically due to the limited availability of warmth around.

In terms of disadvantages, being primarily dependent upon external optimal performance effectiveness reduces colder climates. Additionally, the larger initial investment needed to purchase and install might deter potential buyers, especially those seeking quick solutions to budget constraints. Nonetheless, long-term savings often outweigh expenses given their frequency and duration.

Solar Energy Utilization in Heating Your Pool

As we navigate towards a more sustainable future, solar power emerges as an attractive option for heating pools. Solar pool heaters harness the sun’s abundant energy to warm your swimming area without burning a hole in your pocket or harming the environment.

The Working Mechanism of Solar Pool Heaters

A typical solar pool heater operates on simple principles. The system includes solar collectors—panels that soak up sunlight—and uses this captured heat to increase the water temperature in your swimming pool. This warmed-up water is then circulated back into the main body of the swimming pool using your existing pump setup.

This method requires no additional fuel or electricity, making it highly cost-effective over time. However, bear in mind that these systems depend heavily on sunlight exposure; hence, they perform best under sunny skies and may not be suitable for regions with limited sunshine throughout the year.

Benefits of Using Solar Energy in Heating Pools

Beyond being environmentally friendly, there are several other benefits associated with solar-powered heaters too. They can significantly reduce utility costs linked to traditional gas or electric heaters because their only source of energy is renewable and free – courtesy of Mother Nature.

In addition to lower operating costs, less maintenance might also be required due to fewer moving parts compared to conventional units, which makes them even more appealing. Plus, they’re usually quiet during operation, so you won’t have any noise disturbances while enjoying a relaxing swim.

  1. No greenhouse gases are emitted: Since no fossil fuels are burned during its operation, unlike traditional methods such as gas burners and electrical resistance coils – it’s one way you can contribute positively towards reducing carbon footprint.
  2. Durability: On average, solar panels last longer than most other types of heating equipment available today when maintained properly—that’s quite impressive if longevity matters (and why wouldn’t it?) So although initial installation expenses could seem high at first glance; considering long-term savings and environmental impact, it becomes clear why many homeowners consider this investment worthwhile.

Factors to Consider When Buying a Pool Heater

Purchasing the right pool heater can seem like an uphill task, but understanding the key factors that influence your decision will simplify the process. Let’s dive into these considerations.

Installation Considerations for Different Types of Heaters

The installation procedure differs with each type of pool heater you opt for. Gas heaters are complex and may require professional help due to their need for access to natural gas or propane supply lines. On the other hand, heat pumps might be easier to install on the installation front but require certain placement prerequisites, such as adequate space around them for air circulation.

Solar heaters have another set of unique challenges in terms of installation. They rely heavily on direct sunlight exposure throughout the day, which could limit where they can be installed within your property boundaries while also requiring more space compared to other types.

Importance Of Heating Efficiency In Selecting A Heater

A critical factor when choosing a pool heater is its efficiency rate – how quickly it heats up water and maintains the desired temperature over time without excessive energy consumption. High-efficiency units tend to cost more upfront but offer significant savings in the long term through reduced operational costs.

Apart from a financial perspective, there’s an environmental consideration at stake here: High-efficiency models are a greener option due to their lower fuel consumption, while still providing the same amount of heat as their less efficient counterparts.


  • Fuel Type: Gas-powered systems use either propane or natural gas; electrically powered systems run off standard household electricity; solar-powered systems harness energy directly from the sun.
  • Climatic Conditions: Your local climate plays a crucial role in determining which type of system would work best for your home since some options perform better in certain weather conditions than others.
  • Budget Constraints: Different types of heating solutions vary significantly in terms of initial purchase price and ongoing maintenance costs, so keep your budget in mind when shopping around for a new unit.

If you’re ready to dive into finding the perfect match for your outdoor oasis, explore the pool heaters over at Outdoor Direct. Whether you’re entertaining at home or venturing away, we can assist in bringing your vision to fruition!

Tips on Maximizing Heating Efficiency and Minimizing Waste

Efficiency and conservation are crucial when it comes to operating a pool heater. From the use of covers to specific operational practices, there’s plenty you can do.

Why Use Covers For Retaining Heat And Reducing Evaporation?

A cover is more than just a barrier against debris – it’s an effective tool for heat retention and evaporation reduction. When your pool water evaporates, so does much of its warmth, which makes your heater work overtime trying to keep up with temperature demands.

In fact, regular usage of a swimming pool cover has been found by energy experts to significantly cut down heating costs due to its ability to maintain thermal balance within pools while keeping out unwanted elements that could disrupt filtration systems or cause unnecessary cleaning efforts.

Other Practices To Improve Heating Efficiency

Besides using covers effectively, other methods exist for enhancing efficiency, from adjusting thermostat settings based on user patterns to investing in high-efficiency equipment at the time of purchasing replacement heaters. If nobody plans to swim for extended periods (e.g., overnight during vacations), lowering the temperature rather than turning it off completely can avoid reheating later, which is a beneficial strategy to adopt.

The upfront cost might be higher, but these models often pay for themselves over time thanks to reduced consumption rates. Advanced features like digital thermostats for precise control of temperatures also contribute to minimizing waste without sacrificing comfort levels. Properly sizing the heater according to both the surface area and volume of the pool is another critical aspect to consider. Oversized units consume more power than necessary, while undersized ones struggle to maintain optimal heating, leading to inefficiencies either way.

Regular servicing of all components ensures peak performance, ensuring maximum output per unit input. This also plays a significant role in the overall heating process.

Last but not least, incorporating windbreaks such as landscaping trees and fences around pools reduces the effects of winds cooling the surface waters, thus conserving energy for longer durations. Combined, these practices help create sustainable and enjoyable outdoor environments while keeping utility bills in check.

Essential Maintenance Tips For Your Heater’s Longevity

The longevity and optimal performance of your pool heater are directly linked to regular maintenance. This section provides practical tips that apply to all types of heaters, from gas heaters to electric heat pumps.

Cleaning The Filter Regularly

Your first step in maintaining a well-functioning pool heater is ensuring the filter stays clean. Over time, debris such as leaves or dirt can accumulate within this component, leading to reduced efficiency and potential damage.

To keep your system running smoothly, it is essential that you clean out the filter regularly. While specific cleaning schedules may vary depending on your model’s instructions, generally speaking, a good rule of thumb is to clean at least once every two months during peak usage periods.

Maintaining a Proper Water Chemistry Balance

Balanced water chemistry doesn’t just benefit swimmers – it also extends the lifespan of equipment like natural gas pool heaters by preventing unnecessary wear and tear. Unbalanced pH levels can lead to corrosion or scaling, which reduces heating effectiveness over time.

It’s important to maintain ideal pH levels between 7.4 – 7.6 for pools.

Scheduling Professional Inspections Annually

No matter how diligent you might be about DIY tasks like balancing water temperature using small solar collectors or cleaning filters, an annual inspection by professionals remains indispensable. A certified technician has specialized knowledge about different types, including larger propane ones, along with the necessary tools to perform comprehensive checks efficiently.

Such services ensure any worn-out components get replaced timely, thus prolonging the overall lifespan while keeping heated water warm enough for the swimming season.

Paying Attention To Signs Of Trouble Early On

It’s important to pay attention to any signs of trouble with your pool heater early on. This can help prevent further damage and costly repairs. Look out for warning signs such as strange noises, inconsistent heating, or a decrease in water flow. If you detect any of these indications, it is advisable to take action quickly by calling a specialist technician.


Understanding the different types of pool heaters is your first step in making an informed decision. Gas heaters and heat pumps each have their own unique benefits and limitations.

Solar energy utilization can be a game-changer for eco-conscious homeowners, offering sustainability while heating your pools efficiently.

When buying a pool heater, installation considerations and heating efficiency are crucial factors that should not be overlooked.

Maximizing heating efficiency isn’t just about choosing the right heater; it also involves practices like using covers to retain heat and reduce evaporation, among others.

Maintenance plays a vital role in ensuring optimal performance from your chosen heater as well as prolonging its lifespan. Regular upkeep can save you both time and money down the line


  • Jeremy Treutel

    Jeremy Treutel is a 25-year-old home design blogger from the Midwest. He started blogging in early 2013 as a way to share his passion for design and architecture with the world. Jeremy has written about a wide range of topics, from small home renovations to larger home redesigns. He is also a regular contributor to various home design magazines. Jeremy is a self-taught designer and builder, and he loves using his blog as a way to share his own creative ideas and projects with readers.

Related Posts